Assignment type
Residential appraisal review
An independent opinion of the quality of another appraiser's report — whether its data, analysis and conclusions are supported for the use it was prepared for.
An appraisal review is an opinion about someone else's work, not a second appraisal. The question it answers is whether a report's data, analysis and conclusions are complete, accurate, adequate, relevant and reasonable for the use it was prepared for — and where they are not, exactly where the problem sits.
The scope is agreed before the work starts. A desk review works from the report and its exhibits, checked against market data researched independently. A field review adds an inspection — usually of the subject's exterior, and often of the comparable sales the report relied on. Whether the review also develops its own opinion of value is a separate decision. When it does, that opinion is held to the same development requirements as any appraisal, and it is scoped and quoted accordingly.
The reviewer is independent of the original appraiser and of whoever commissioned the review, and the review does not rewrite or correct the original report. It identifies what is supported and what is not, and says why. A review that finds the original work well supported is a legitimate result, and the one to expect when the work was sound.
In contested estate and divorce matters, the practical use of a review is that it makes a disagreement specific. Instead of two numbers argued in the abstract, a difference is traced to a particular comparable, adjustment or assumption, and the reasoning on each side can be examined on its merits.
What you receive
A written review report identifying the report under review and the scope of the review, with a supported opinion on the quality of the work — and an opinion of value only where the scope includes one.
What to have ready
- A complete copy of the report under review, including addenda and exhibits
- Who will rely on the review — counsel, the court, the owner, or an institution
- Whether a desk review is enough or a field inspection is needed
- Whether the scope should include an opinion of value
- The effective date of the original report, and any deadline driving the timetable
- What prompted the review — the specific points you want examined
Common questions
- Is a review the same as a second appraisal?
- No. A review is an opinion about the quality of another appraiser's work — whether its conclusions are supported for its intended use. It includes an opinion of value only if that is part of the agreed scope, and that part is then developed to the same standard as an appraisal. If what you actually need is an independent value, a new appraisal may be the more direct route, and that is worth settling at intake.
- Will the review say the other appraiser got it wrong?
- It will say what the evidence supports. Some reviews find a report well supported; others find specific problems with the data, the adjustments or the reasoning. The conclusion is not known before the work is done, and a review written toward a predetermined answer would not survive examination.
- I have questions about the appraisal my lender ordered. Can a review change the lender's decision?
- Not on its own. The lender is the intended user of its own report and makes its own decisions, and a review commissioned by a borrower cannot compel it to reconsider. Many lenders have a process for reconsidering a value, and a review can set out specific, documented concerns in a form that process can use. Ask your lender how it handles those requests, and whether it will consider outside material, before commissioning one.
- Can a review be used in a contested matter?
- It is written so it can be examined — the scope, the evidence and the reasoning are stated rather than summarised. Whether and how it is used is a matter for counsel. Deposition or testimony, if it may be needed, should be raised at intake because it changes the scope of work from the start.
Related assignment types
Divorce & marital asset division
Independent valuation of the marital residence for dissolution proceedings, with an effective date matched to the requirements of the case.
Estate & date-of-death valuations
Retrospective market value as of a date of death, prepared for estate settlement, probate filings and stepped-up basis documentation.
Discuss appraisal review.
Call (314) 315-2005 with the property, the purpose and the effective date, and you will get a straight answer on scope, timing and fee.
