Skip to content
The bandstand in Forest Park, St. Louis, reflected in the lake at sunset in autumn

For attorneys & CPAs

Appraisals written to be argued with.

You are putting your own credibility behind whoever you refer. This page is what you need to decide whether that is a reasonable thing to do.

Most of the work that reaches this practice from attorneys and accountants has two properties in common: the effective date is not today, and someone on the other side has a reason to disagree with the number.

Both change how a report has to be written. A retrospective valuation cannot lean on current market data, so the sales it relies on have to be located in the right period and the market conditions of that period have to be established rather than assumed. And a report that will be argued with has to show its reasoning: every adjustment with a stated basis, every thin patch in the data acknowledged, every assumption written down where it can be examined.

That is the whole proposition. Not a faster turnaround, not a cheaper fee, and emphatically not a number that helps your client’s position. A defensible file.

What to have ready

Five minutes on the phone is usually enough to scope an assignment, and these are what make that call short:

  • Property address

    and, if you have it, the parcel number.

  • Purpose

    estate, divorce, tax appeal, bankruptcy, planning.

  • Effective date

    date of death, separation, filing, or current.

  • Intended users

    who will rely on the report — this goes in it.

  • Deadline

    court date, filing date, or appeal window.

  • Access

    who lets me in, and whether an interior inspection is possible.

By practice area

Estate & probate attorneys

Date-of-death valuations, estate settlement, retrospective appraisals

Usually a retrospective effective date, often years back, and frequently on a property that has since changed hands or been cleared. The report has to reconstruct the market as of that date and show its work.

Family law attorneys

Divorce and marital asset division

The effective date matters as much as the value — separation, filing or trial. Agreed before the assignment starts, stated plainly in the report.

CPAs & financial planners

Gift tax, estate planning, cost basis documentation

Documentation built to survive review rather than to reach a number. Where a fractional or partial interest is involved, say so at intake — it changes the assignment.

Bankruptcy attorneys

Asset schedules

A current, defensible market value for schedules, on a timetable that is usually set by a filing date rather than by convenience.

How engagement works

Independence is the product

The engagement can be with one party, both jointly, or the court, and that relationship is disclosed in the report. What it does not do is change the analysis. An appraisal that moves with whoever is paying for it is worth nothing to you the moment it is challenged.

The effective date is agreed before the work starts

Retrospective assignments live or die on this. Date of death, date of separation, date of filing, the assessment year under appeal — tell me the date and the purpose at intake and the analysis is built to it.

Reports are written to be read by someone who will argue with them

Adjustments are shown and reasoned rather than asserted. Where the data is thin — a period with few sales, an unusual property, a reconstructed condition — the report says so rather than papering over it.

Tell me the deadline at intake

Court dates, filing deadlines and Missouri's assessment appeal calendar are fixed and unforgiving. Turnaround depends on the assignment type, the effective date and how much reconstruction the property needs; you will get a straight answer on the call rather than a number on a webpage.

Expert witness work and litigation support are handled case by case. If deposition or testimony is a possibility, say so at intake — it affects the scope of work and the level of documentation from the start, and it is far cheaper to build that in than to add it later.

Scope an assignment in five minutes.

Call (314) 315-2005 or send the property, purpose, effective date and deadline and you will get a straight answer on scope, timing and fee.